Dispatcher vs broker: one works for the freight, one works for you
Both of them talk to you about loads. Both of them talk about rates. That is where the similarity ends. A freight broker is hired by the shipper to move freight and earns the gap between what the shipper pays and what you accept. A truck dispatcher is hired by you, the carrier, to find and negotiate those loads for your truck, and gets paid by you. Mix them up and you end up asking the wrong person to fight for your rate.
Freight broker vs dispatcher vs carrier, side by side
Four questions decide which role a company is playing: does it register with FMCSA, who does it work for, who pays it, and does it have to post money to protect the people it deals with. Each answer below links the rule it comes from. Checked October 2026.
| Question | Freight broker | Motor carrier (you) | Dispatch service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Registration with FMCSA | Broker operating authority, its own authority type with its own fee and BOC-3.FMCSA registration | USDOT number plus for-hire carrier operating authority to haul regulated freight across state lines.FMCSA registration | None of its own when it acts as the carrier's bona fide agent. It works under your authority, not a separate one.FMCSA guidance, 88 FR 39368 |
| Who it works for | The shipper's freight. It arranges transportation by an authorized carrier, for compensation.49 CFR 371.2 | Itself. It accepts the load, legally binds itself to haul it and does the hauling.49 CFR 371.2 | The carrier that appointed it, under a written agreement, following the carrier's directions.49 CFR 371.2 |
| Who pays it | The shipper, who pays the broker more than the broker pays the carrier. The spread is the broker's income.49 CFR 371.3 | The broker or shipper, directly or through a factoring company, at the rate on the rate confirmation. | The carrier only. FMCSA lists taking pay from a broker, 3PL or factor as a sign of brokering.FMCSA guidance, 88 FR 39368 |
| Bond or trust fund | $75,000 surety bond (BMC-84) or trust fund (BMC-85) before FMCSA will register it.49 CFR 387.307 | No bond. Liability insurance filed with FMCSA instead, $750,000 minimum for general freight.49 CFR 387.9 | No federal bond. It never holds the freight money, so there is nothing to bond.FMCSA guidance, 88 FR 39368 |
The short version: the broker is a registered, bonded middleman on the freight side, and the dispatcher is your agent on the carrier side. For the registration paperwork itself, our guide to broker authority vs carrier authority walks through both filings, and the broker MC number guide covers the broker side on its own.
Who pays whom: follow one load's money
Most of the confusion between a dispatcher and a broker disappears when you trace the money on a single load. Here is the order it moves in.
01 →
Shipper to broker
The shipper agrees a price with the broker to move the freight. You usually never see that number.
02 →
Broker to carrier
The broker offers you a rate, and the rate confirmation names your company, your MC and the amount. After delivery, the broker pays that amount to you, or to your factoring company if you factor.
03 →
Carrier to dispatcher
You pay your dispatcher a percentage of the gross you were paid. On this desk that is 5% standard, invoiced weekly against a report of every load.
EXAMPLEA broker books a load with you at $2,400. Whatever the shipper paid the broker stays between them. You invoice $2,400 and get paid $2,400 by the broker or your factor. At 5%, you then owe your dispatcher $120. The dispatcher never touched the $2,400.
That last line matters more than it looks. FMCSA's 2023 guidance says a dispatch service that is not an intermediary in the money between broker and carrier, and that is paid by the carrier under a written contract, generally does not need broker authority. A dispatcher who collects your load pay and passes some of it along is in the middle of that transaction, and that is one of the signs FMCSA lists for brokering.
One more thing brokers do not advertise: federal rules require them to keep a record of each brokered transaction for three years, including the compensation they received, and each party to the transaction has the right to review it.49 CFR 371.3
When a dispatcher is acting like a broker
FMCSA examined dispatch services in a final guidance published June 16, 2023, after Congress asked it to. The agency did not ban dispatchers; it said a dispatch service can be a bona fide agent or a broker depending on what it actually does, and listed the signs on each side. A shortened version:
Signs of a carrier's agent
- A written contract appointing it as the carrier's agent
- Books through brokers and does not solicit shippers
- Paid by the carrier, not by the broker, 3PL or factor
- Stays out of the payment between broker and carrier
- Says it is a dispatch service working for a named carrier
- Never hands the load to a different carrier
Signs it needs broker authority
- Negotiates freight directly with the shipper
- Takes compensation from the broker or factor
- Books loads with no written contract with the carrier
- Accepts a load first, then looks for a truck
- Chooses which of its carriers gets a load
- Shops the load to the open market of carriers
The guidance stresses control: the more the carrier directs the dispatcher, the less room the dispatcher has to allocate freight on its own. That is also the best test you can run yourself. Whether your own dispatcher needs an MC of their own is covered in our guide on whether a dispatcher needs an MC number.
How this dispatch desk is set up
You appoint us in writing
The dispatch service runs under a written agreement sent after we talk, so the relationship FMCSA describes is on paper from day one.
Your MC on every rate con
Loads are searched for your truck and booked in your company's name. The rate confirmation goes from the broker directly to you.
You confirm every load
Nothing moves until you say yes, and you can simply say no. A dispatcher that commits your truck without asking is making decisions FMCSA expects the carrier to make.
The freight money skips us
Brokers pay you or your factor. We invoice our percentage separately each week, on loads you actually hauled.
7% while your MC is under 6 months, dropping to 5% automatically; 5% for one truck with 6 months or more; 4% per truck for fleets of 2 or more. No setup fee, no minimums, month-to-month with 30 days notice. No haul, no pay. Every tier is broken down on the truck dispatch fees page.
Dispatcher vs broker FAQs
What is the difference between a dispatcher and a freight broker?
A freight broker arranges transportation for the shipper's freight, holds its own FMCSA broker authority and a $75,000 bond or trust fund, and earns the spread between the shipper's price and your rate. A dispatcher works for the carrier, books loads through brokers for the carrier's truck, and is paid by the carrier under a written agreement.
Does a truck dispatcher need broker authority?
Not when it works as the carrier's bona fide agent. FMCSA's June 2023 guidance says a dispatch service with a written agency contract, paid by the carrier and staying out of the broker-carrier payment, generally does not. Negotiating with shippers, taking money from brokers or choosing between its carriers for a load points toward needing it. This is not legal advice.
Who pays a truck dispatcher?
The carrier does. The broker pays the carrier for the load, or pays the carrier's factoring company, and the carrier then pays the dispatcher its agreed share. Here that share is 5% of gross for one truck with 6 months of authority or more, 7% under 6 months and 4% per truck for fleets.
Can a dispatcher also be a broker?
A company can hold broker authority and also run dispatch, but it then sits on both sides of the rate: it profits from paying carriers less as a broker and from carriers earning more as a dispatcher. If a dispatcher you are vetting also brokers, ask which hat it wears on each load and get the answer in writing.
What is broker authority vs carrier authority?
Carrier authority lets your company haul regulated freight for pay across state lines in your own trucks. Broker authority lets a company arrange that transportation with authorized carriers for pay, and requires the $75,000 bond or trust fund. They are separate authority types with separate applications and fees on FMCSA's registration system.
Every truck we dispatch, same desk
Every page here is part of one truck dispatch service that works for the carrier on the same terms. Brokers often pay on 30 day terms; if that gap hurts, compare freight factoring before you book your next week.
- Box truck dispatch26 ft and up: partials, final mile, expedited
- Hot shot dispatchCDL and non-CDL hotshot rigs
- Dry van dispatchSteady van freight, setups cleared
- Reefer dispatchProduce seasons and setpoints in writing
- Flatbed dispatchSecurement checked, tarp pay agreed
- Step deck dispatchTall freight that will not clear a flatbed
- Power only dispatchYour tractor, preloaded trailers
By situation: New authority dispatch · Owner operator dispatch · Small fleet dispatch · Can't find loads? · Dispatcher vs load board · How truck dispatch works · Regional dispatch service · Southeast truck dispatch · Slow freight market dispatch · After a lease-purchase
Put somebody on your side of the rate con
A dispatcher who answers to you, books in your name and never touches your load pay. 5% standard, month-to-month, every load your call.